Name: __________________________________________
Copyright
by
The
Goodheart-Willcox
Co.,
Inc.
Lesson 3 Click Ball 51
Design Reasoning—Peer Evaluation
Peer Evaluator: ___________________________________________________________________
Comments and Constructive Criticism
Explain your score for each item. Explain what you liked about the item and how it should
be improved. Be detailed and complete. Cite specific examples from the game. Attach additional
sheets if needed or complete using a word processor.
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
Scores for items not fully documented and cited may reduce the score of the peer
evaluator and the evaluator’s game project. Be honest and provide constructive criticism. Being
unprofessional or lowering a grade on a personal issue unrelated to the game design will result
in your grade for this evaluation being lowered.
0 1 2 3 4 5 Score
Concept
Is the idea well developed?
No main idea. Clear
throughout.
Aesthetics
Do the look and colors
fi t the game?
Poor quality graphics
and color.
Awesome graphics
and theme-based
colors.
Sound Effects
Do the sounds play well?
Are the music and ambient
sounds appropriate?
No sound; sounds
too loud or not
related to the game.
Good sound for each
item at good levels.
Functionality
Does everything work?
Unfi nished, could not
play; major errors
Plays perfectly; no
bugs, glitches or errors
Replay
How likely are you to
play this game again?
Game solved,
too easy or
uninteresting.
Cannot wait to play
this again!
Total Score
(higher is better)